Propane information related to forklifts, warehousing, and energy savings

Forklift

It's a Beautiful Day at Work, Not a Cloud in the Warehouse

 

More than 600,000 forklifts are powered by propane in factories and warehouses. And it's no wonder. Propane-powered forklifts provide operational options and economic advantages that make them a clear choice for your material handling needs.


The reasons for choosing propane forklifts and for converting existing gasoline forklifts to operate on propane are plentiful.

  • Environmentally Friendly: Propane is a non-toxic, clean-burning fuel that can be used to safely power forklifts both indoors and outdoors. With propane, there is no spillage loss or evaporation into the atmosphere.
  • Safe: Propane forklift tanks, fuel lines and carburetion components meet or exceed strict specifications. Built-in safety devices automatically shut off the flow of fuel in case of an accident.
  • Versatile: Propane forklifts can be used in indoor and outdoor applications. Propane is the most portable fuel — cylinders can be stored and moved virtually anywhere within a work site.
  • Strong: Propane forklifts maintain consistent, 100-percent power throughout operation. They have the ability to push and pull heavy loads at full capacity, up and down inclines, for a longer amount of time, and with better ground speeds than electric forklifts.
  • Easy Refueling: Propane forklifts require very little refueling time compared to natural gas-powered and electric forklifts.
  • Economical: From an investment standpoint, propane forklifts offer an economical way to meet material handling needs. Propane forklifts have lower life-cycle costs than electric, diesel or gasoline-powered forklifts.
  • Low Maintenance: Propane produces fewer engine deposits than gasoline and diesel fuel, resulting in lower maintenance costs. Propane engines can typically last up to twice as long as gasoline engines.

Comparison of Forklift Attributes

FuelVersatilityCost
Propane
  • Capable of handling rugged, unpaved, outdoor terrain, and steep grades
  • Indoor and outdoor use
  • Can operate in inclement weather
  • Lower initial investment costs than comparable electric, CNG or diesel forklifts,
  • Lower maintenance costs than diesel and electric forklifts
  • Inexpensive cylinder exchange or onsite fuel storage
  • Pilfer-proof; reduced loss from spillage and evaporation
Diesel
  • Predominantly outdoor use only
  • Additional cost due to pilfering, spillage losses, evaporation
CNG
  • Similar to propane
  • Recertification costs: CNG cylinders must be recertified every three years
  • Establishments with CNG forklift fleet may require major capital investment of up to $40,000 in refueling station
  • If the electric service goes down, the CNG compressor station will not work resulting in a potentially significant production loss CNG compressors are expensive to overhaul
Electricity
  • Typically for indoor use
  • Operate only on paved or hard surfaces
  • Cannot handle steep inclines
  • Ventilated storage area is required for batteries
  • Additional indoor space for recharger and battery storage
  • Labor costs for changing batteries for second and third shifts
  • Extra equipment such as batteries, charger, and battery hoist, battery charging and wash down rooms
Gasoline
  • Typically for outdoor use
  • Additional cost due to pilfering, spillage losses, evaporation
  • High costs to upgrade on-site fuel storage


Comparison of Forklift Operating Characteristics

FuelPowerApproximate Operating Time (Per Tank or Battery)Maintenance
Propane
  • Maintains 100% power consistently throughout full operation
  • Lift (loaded): 83-88 fpm
  • Speed (max): 9.5-10.5 mph
8 hours (1 shift)
  • Maintenance intervals may be extended because of propane's clean-burning characteristics
  • Easy maintenance
Diesel
  • Speed (max): 9.5-10.5 mph
  • Lift (loaded): 83-88 fpm
8 hours (1 shift)
  • Requires expensive oil changess
CNG
  • Speed (max): 9.5-10.5 mph
  • Lift (loaded): 74-78 fpm
2-4 hours (¼- ½ shift)
  • Requires frequent refueling
  • CNG compressors will require expensive overhaul
Electricity
  • Speed (max): 8-9 mph
  • Lift (loaded): 83-88 fpmm
  • Loses power as battery discharges
6-8 hours (¾- 1 shift)
  • Requires additional training
  • Maintenance intervals depend on conditions
  • Must operate in a controlled environment (e.g., not in the rain)
  • Second and third shifts requires labor for battery change
Gasoline
  • Speed (max): 9.5-10.5 mph
  • Lift (loaded): 83-88 fpm
8 hours (1 shift)
  • Requires more frequent oil changes than propane

Source: National Propane Gas Association 

There are seven classes of forklifts:

 

  • Class 1: Electric motor, sit-down rider, counterbalanced trucks (both solid and pneumatic tires)
  • Class 2: Electric motor, narrow aisle trucks (solid tires)
  • Class 3: Electric motor hand trucks or hand/rider trucks (solid tires)
  • Class 4: Internal combustion engine trucks (solid tires)
  • Class 5: Internal combustion engine trucks (pneumatic tires)
  • Class 6: Electric & internal combustion engine tractors (both solid and pneumatic tires)
  • Class 7: Rough terrain forklift trucks (pneumatic tires)

Propane forklifts are primarily Class 4 and Class 5 forklifts.